Thinking and Reasoning

How to Make a Group Decision When Everyone Has Different Priorities

Agree on which tradeoffs to compare before choosing between options. If you can reverse the decision, try it for a set period and decide in advance what feedback you’ll review.

Fictional story

What to try

  1. Ask each person for one criterion they care about, such as cost, accessibility or attendance.
  2. Record what each option does well, then choose a review date and who will gather observations.

Blank boxes on the sign-up sheet

The reading group needed a new meeting time. Saturday was popular among current members. Tuesday meant the library could provide a room for free. A third organizer wanted the option that would bring in more people who had never attended.

Agreeing on what to compare

Instead of voting again, Raul asked them to write down what each schedule would make easier and harder. They added attendance, cost, and availability for newcomers to a short list. One option looked weaker after they asked first-time visitors when they could attend.

The trial had a cost

The Tuesday room was free, but it closed earlier. The organizers had to shorten the discussion and find another place to stack chairs. That inconvenience had been easy to overlook on paper. After two meetings they asked everyone to record one thing that had become easier and one thing they were now having trouble with.

Trying the reversible choice

They booked Tuesday for one month and kept Saturday open if the trial was hard to attend. The library asked for a decision by Friday, so the group agreed on the information it would review when the month ended.

Using the information they promised to review

At the end of the month two newcomers had attended regularly and one regular member had stopped coming. The group decided to keep Tuesday and add a longer Saturday session once a month. Raul remembered how certain each person had sounded at the first meeting. What helped later was having a clear record of which tradeoffs the group had been willing to try.

Notice your decision habits

The decision-making assessment can help you reflect on habits such as defining criteria and considering alternatives. Think about how you choose when there is a deadline or when several people care about the outcome.

What if the group still can’t agree on the criteria?

Ask which criteria are requirements and which are preferences. For anything still disputed, identify who is affected and what information would help resolve it.

Further reading